What's your news flash? Send it to ed@edhat.com login  twitter  facebook  RSS 

Advertise on Edhat
Advertise on Edhat
News Events Referrals Deals Classifieds Comments About

more articles like this

I’m Sick of These Plants
updated: Aug 14, 2010, 10:00 AM

By Billy Goodnick

Landscape designers can get a little full of themselves, me included. We know so many more plants than you do and can recite polysyllabic botanical names like Parthenocissus tricuspidata without coming up for air.

Discovering a cool, new Heuchera with crinkled, copper-colored leaves and chartreuse polka dots is like a crack head's deep toke smacking the brain with a dopamine two-by-four. Then comes the roller coaster ride - cosmic sensations of euphoria and empowerment, then the inevitable crushing crash. The story endlessly repeats as we find ourselves down some sketchy alley, peering over the nursery wall, scouting our next fix.

The trouble is, some of the shiny new plants designers get all throbby about haven't been around long enough to reliably know what happens ten years down the line.

Sometimes it's safer to work with the plants we see every day. There's a reason they're so damn ubiquitous. They're everywhere because they'll grow anywhere, whether you're a Master Gardener or a nursery newbie.

Sure, I would love to design every project as an artistic and botanical adventure, but that's not realistic. For many clients, it is preferable to create a garden filled with common, but thriving plants that require minimal resources, than to create a short-lived masterpiece of exotica that demands constant life-support.

My first job when I moved to Santa Barbara in the 70s was at La Sumida Nursery's flagship store on upper State Street. 40 years later that location is shuttered, but I know that a lot of the same plants I sold back then are still in service in local gardens.

I motored out to the Patterson Avenue La Sumida Nursery to see if anything has changed, and struck up a conversation with Kevin Gibson, a nurseryman with many years in the business. Kevin is a pragmatist and although he calls them "been there, done that plants," he also says, "There's a reason we see so many of these everywhere - they work."

If I described an unexciting, cookie-cutter, done-that plant palette to another designer, I'd use the shorthand of "nothing but rhaphs, agapanthus and gazania" and they'd know just what I mean. Let's start with those…

You can't throw a garden gnome with a broken arm and not hit some form of Indian hawthorne (Rhaphiolepis indica). Its varieties and cultivars range from the massive R. ‘Majestic Beauty' that eventually achieves treelike proportions, to R. i. ‘Ballerina', topping out at barely 2 feet and spreading 4 feet wide. With the exception of a few white-flowering varieties (R. i. ‘Clara' is the most common), rhaphs come in varying shades of pink.

They thrive in full sun but can tolerate partial shade, though they won't flower as prolifically. You might find a few aphids on the flower buds in early spring, but that's no big deal - hose them off or wait for the hungry, good bugs. Otherwise, rhaphs are pretty much pest-free and need only a little water once established.

Pleeeeease don't shear these guys into meatloaves or floating discs! Start smart by picking the right size plant for the space you have, not one that will overrun its limits. If it needs a little shaping, just pinch or snip the tip growth right after the plant finishes flowering.

Some rhaphs bloom sporadically throughout the year, but by summertime they're pretty much just a green bush -- a neutral backdrop for the rest of your garden. Though not particularly showy, most varieties produce dark-purple berries. You might see a few bright crimson leaves here and there when cold weather comes.

You can get sick of Lily-of-the-Nile (Agapanthus species), with its showy blue or white flowers but I can't do without them. When summer arrives, gardens explode with spherical clusters of small, funnel-shaped flowers balanced on fleshy green stalks. No longer are we limited to the big, honkin' A. praecox orientalis of yesteryear, with its 4 to 5 foot stalks. Hybridizers have been messing with Agapanthus with great results. Look for mini-versions like ‘Peter Pan' or deep violet-blue forms like ‘Storm Cloud'. Others have white striped leaves that brighten a garden bed after the flowers fade.

If snails set up housekeeping in the moist, dark spaces under the plants, apply Sluggo, a pet-safe product available at Sumida's and most local nurseries.

I remember Gazania daisies from my childhood in LA's San Fernando Valley. Leisure summer afternoons were spent on the front lawn, slowly dismembering the orange, rust and brown-striped petals from the fleshy stems. Gazanias come in two basic categories - clumping and trailing. (I think that's self-explanatory.) Most gazanias have flowers in the warm color range - yellow, gold, orange, rust - with a few types pushing into the reddish-purple range. These South African perennial ground covers require occasional summer irrigation and grow in soils enriched with organic compost or in lean, unamended soils - they don't seem to care. The trailing type looks great spilling over a wall and their tolerance for salt spray makes them practical in coastal areas.

I bitch and moan about people shoving bougainvillea (Bougainvillea species) into absurdly small spaces, but I don't hate the plant. Bougies can't be beat for explosions of summer color. From virginal white through gold, pink and sultry lipstick-red, it puts on a helluva show.

I love the plant. However, I also understand and respect the unalterable genetic programming that compels bougainvillea to spread near and far, smothering entire zip codes like in a 50s sci-fi movie.

Now pay attention! These are your horticultural Miranda rights: Left alone, the majority of bougies will grow into a thicket at least 10 feet tall by 20 feet wide - some brutes get much bigger. Even the purportedly well-behaved B. ‘Rosenka', with its showy pinkish-orangey bracts (the colorful "flower" is actually a modified, papery leaf surrounding a small white flower in the center - take a look sometime) gets really big. The park crews frequently pull out a chainsaw to tame the beautiful bougie hedge at Alice Keck.

Here's a picture of one humping the Lobero Building near Santa Barbara's main post office.

See what I told you? In the words of a recent president, don't misunderestimate bougainvillea.

If you're thinking of planting some on a fence or over an arbor, do not expect it to daintily wander about. Prepare to mount a perpetual state of war with this viciously hooked thorn-monster.

I crack up when I see massive blocks of heavily sheared bougainvillea in a too-small space. I'd bet a week's pay that someone chose that bougainvillea because of the pretty flowers. The joke is that usually there aren't any - just green leaves, sticks and thorns. Why? Because bougainvillea blooms on its new tip growth, all of which gets sheared off, raked up and hauled away (hopefully, to be recycled). Sounds like a job for Sisyphus.

The moral? Think before you plant, and don't say I didn't warn you.

To Be Continued…

I'm already at 1111 words and that's probably all that Ed's, your and my attention spans can handle. I still want to talk about a few more of the hardest working plants in the garden, so mark your calendar and check in again in two weeks (that'd be Sunday, August 29). I'll fill you in on the love/hate relationship I have with some of our area's most dependable but hackneyed plants.

Before You Go, Watch Me On PBS

You are invited to watch me on Growing A Greener World; a PBS sustainable landscaping TV show, hosted by Joe Lamp'l. He and his co-hosts, Garden Girl Patti Moreno, and Chef Nathan Lyons, have been traveling around the country, visiting homes, farms, community gardens, parks and the people who are providing enlightened environmental stewardship through horticulture and gardening. It's inspiring and sprinkled with great do-it-yourself tips and cooking ideas, too.

Joe has a great sense of fun, so when he started planning his episode about pruning, he figured it would be a hoot to have me on the show for a live-action version of my Crimes Against Horticulture schtick. We rendezvoused in LA in June and ran around in front of the cameras all morning, filming the bizarre things that happen when the wrong plant goes in the wrong place. The show airs on Blue Ridge PBS (I'm sorry to say the show hasn't been picked up by KCET yet), then moves to the Growing A Greener World website on Saturday, August 14. Look for Episode #114. I haven't seen a preview, but I'm told there are some fun out-takes during the closing titles, so hang on to the bitter end.

See you in two weeks.

Comments in order of when they were received | (reverse order)

 COMMENT 97765 agree helpful negative off topic

2010-08-14 10:22 AM



 COMMENT 97766 agree helpful negative off topic

2010-08-14 10:31 AM

Tried and true plants are indeed, just that, tried and true. La Sumida is pretty good for those. For the more interesting stuff I prefer Terra Sol.


 COMMENT 97803 agree helpful negative off topic

2010-08-14 12:06 PM

For great prices, I like Knapp Nursery. I went to get common day lilies and was pleasantly surprised with double flowers, looks similar to a rose. Very pretty!


 CHERIDIANE agree helpful negative off topic

2010-08-14 09:44 PM

Because of something Billy Goodnick said in an earlier EdHat article, I think it was, I spent a lovely time recently touring Seaside Nursery and Botanical Gardens. What a find! In Carpinteria.

Thank you for another bit of reading fun and information here. I look forward to two weeks from now! Cheers!


 COMMENT 97887P agree helpful negative off topic

2010-08-15 06:27 AM

Lots of good information!

I've had to endure a self-imposed 12 to 200 step program to stop buying plants. Terra Sol Nursery is a place where I can easily relapse.


 COMMENT 97894 agree helpful negative off topic

2010-08-15 07:56 AM

If only I knew then what I know now... I am one of those bougainvillea trimmers. Until I figure out what to replace it with, I am destined to prune.


 COMMENT 97901 agree helpful negative off topic

2010-08-15 08:48 AM

Super article! Thank you for all the information (and humor!).


 COMMENT 97929 agree helpful negative off topic

2010-08-15 10:30 AM

...nothing wrong with pruning a bougainvillea, just don't hockey-puck it or meatloaf it...it's always better to thin than to truncate. So remove some main branches back to the truck, and tip-prune others for a more open look.

Often, with mid-summer pruning, after the main bloom, the plant responds with less forceful regrowth. If you prune too hard too early, all you get is a jungle-y regrowth of enormous proportions rather than a more lightly stimulated repsonse. This is true of ruit trees as well. Moderate dormant season pruning (thinning rather than scalping) will result in less vigourious summer grwoth. You can then follow fruiting with a light pruning that will help maintain a lower (easier to pick and prune) branch scaffold.


 COMMENT 97936 agree helpful negative off topic

2010-08-15 11:25 AM

Hi Billy, Love your posts. You are so right about the tried and true. Sure love those Agapanthas when they arrive each season like happy children ready to play. The last of the bloomed out stalks just got lopped off and I sure miss them. The gophers love our bougainvillas as much as we do...unfortunately. We lose one or two every year (even though we plant them in cages). Thank goodness they are fairly easy to replace.
Thanks for keeping us up on the dirt around the gardens in town.


 COMMENT 97943 agree helpful negative off topic

2010-08-15 12:14 PM

One thing to remember with Agapanthas is that gophers love 'em. I have a job where I work long hours. Noticed a couple of Agapanthas missing on Monday. By the time the weekend came and I had time to do something about it, gophers had gone through over $100 of Agapanthas. It would have been cheaper to buy them dinner.

With bougainvillea, please don't plant it by your front or back door. I think I still have scars from carrying groceries and other things in and being attacked by thorns that yes, I should have know were right there.


 COMMENT 97979 agree helpful negative off topic

2010-08-15 04:48 PM

I remember your previous comments disparaging the common impatiens. Here in Cambria we have glorious displays, all in jewel tones, and I wish I could duplicate that at my home. There IS something to be said about successfully growing successful stars.


18% of comments on this page were made by Edhat Community Members.



Add Your Comments

Edhat Username



Don't have an Account?

Don't know if you have an account?

Don't remember your account info?


ENJOY HAPPY HOUR! ... Between 4:00pm & 5:00pm only happy comment are allowed on the Edhat Comments Board.

If you can't say something nice, don't say nothing at all.

Hide Your Handle
NOTE: We are testing a new Comment Preview Page. You must hit OK on the next page to have your comment go live. Send Feedback to ed@edhat.com.

get a handle   |  lost handle




  See more articles like this

# # # #


Send To a Friend
Your Email
Friend's Email

Top of Page | Printer-Friendly Page

  Home Subscribe FAQ Jobs Contact copyright © 2003-2015  
Edhat, Inc.